Page 451 - Contributed Paper Session (CPS) - Volume 2
P. 451

CPS1922 Imran K. et al.
            * There were differences between groups in aerobic training [F(3,514) = 3.588, p = 0.014]
            Table-3
                                   Age (years)        Height (cm)        Weight (kg)
             Group        N        M        SD       M        SD        M        SD
             Active       6       27.0     (9.7)    161.8     (5.9)    57.1      (4.7)
             Passive      6       22.3     (2.3)    163.9     (5.9)    62.5     (15.6)
             Control      6       26.3     (5.3)    175.3    (6.4)*    71.6     (15.3)
            M = Mean; SD = Standard Deviation; *p<0.05.

                In Table-3 the baseline character (Height) is found to be significant which
            is believed to act as confounding variable and has not been taken care of while
            discussing the main results.

            Table-4
                Total Turnout      Professionals       Collegiate         Academy
               Measurements
             RI (Mean ± SD)      127.61° ± 14.39°   105.35° ± 16.54°   123.93° ± 17.56°
             Floor (Mean ± SD)    142.7° ± 13.88°   115.12° ± 16.54°   134.98° ± 12.39°

                While discussing Table-4 in the results section of the paper the author
            explains  interaction  as  Non-Sig.  and  the  main  effects  are  found  to  be
            significant which are nowhere displayed in the table.

            Table-5
                                   Non-Dancer        Thai Classical       P-Value
                                     Control            Dancer
             Age (years)           21.16 ± 0.38       21.23 ± 0.46         0.087
             Weight (kg)           51.42 ± 5.07       45.67 ± 2.09         0.049*
             Height (cm)          156.73 ± 3.46      158.01 ± 3.50         0.568
             Years Dancing              0             11.36 ± 2.91

                Controls are taken as non-dancers who have never attended any dance
            classes. The controls have not been selected as per scientific/statistical criteria.
            Hence, the comparison is definitely biased/incorrect











                                                               440 | I S I   W S C   2 0 1 9
   446   447   448   449   450   451   452   453   454   455   456